I think Cookie Monster just might approve of these cupcakes. Like him, I've had a special sweet tooth for cookies and cream lately, in fact a pint of Ben & Jerry's Milk and Cookies is waiting not so patiently for me in the freezer! This cupcake recipe and all its questions have been brewing in my head and making my stomach grumble for quite a while-Cookies in the cupcake or just in the frosting? Cookies crushed in the batter or flat on the bottom? With the help of my handy mom and sister, the final decision was crumbled cookies in the batter and in the frosting too! A little bit of cookie in every layer and bite of the cupcake. I decided to not even make the next decision of golden oreos or chocolate oreos and just used both. I paired each cookie with a box cake and some buttercream, then with a few smashes of the rolling pin and spins of the mixer I had a tasty cookie cupcake treat.
Chocolate Oreo Cake Ingredients
1box Devil's Food Cake mix (plus oil, water, and eggs according to box instructions)
20 Oreo cookies, chopped
Golden Oreo Cake Ingredients
1 box Yellow Cake mix (plus oil, water, and eggs according to box instructions)
20 Golden Oreo cookies, chopped
Cookies and Buttercream Frosting
1/2 cup butter
2 cups powdered sugar
1 tsp vanilla
Milk for texture
14 crushed Oreo cookies (chocolate Oreos for the Devil's Food and Golden Oreos for the Yellow cake)
1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
2. Line cupcake trays with paper cupcake liners.
3. Place 20 Oreo cookies in a large ziplock bag.
4. Chop Oreos with the handle of a rolling pin, spoon, spatula, or whatever works!
5. Mix together cake mix, oil, water, and eggs according to box instructions.
6. Stir in crushed Oreo cookies.
7. Fill cupcake liners 3/4 full, making sure there are plenty of cookie chunks in each.
8. Bake according to box instructions, staying on the lesser side of the time range.
9. Let cupcakes cool and take a taste or two to make sure they're aok!
10. Meanwhile, mix butter and powdered sugar together.
11. Mix in vanilla.
12. Add milk small amounts at a time until desired texture.
13. Place 14 Oreo cookies in a large ziplock bag.
14. Crush Oreos using a rolling pin.
15. Mix in crushed Oreos.
16. Spread cupcakes with cookies and buttercream frosting.
17. Enjoy your cookies and cake all in one, and don't forget the milk!